TaxPage - Employee Shareholdings – How Can Tax Pitfalls Be Avoided?
Introduction
Employee shareholdings enable companies to attract and retain key personnel and give them a stake in the company's success. For start-ups in particular, they can help preserve liquidity and create additional incentives for management in the event of a company sale. However, they raise key questions: Do the proceeds qualify as a tax-free private capital gain or constitute taxable employment income? And what are the resulting tax implications for the company?
New FTA Guidance
The Swiss Federal Tax Administration (FTA) published Circular No. 51 on treasury shares on 5 November 2026 and Circular No. 37A on the tax treatment of employee shareholdings at employer level on 6 November 2026. The circulars clarify the acquisition and reissuance of treasury shares and the treatment of business expenses. Circular No. 37 remains authoritative for the taxation of employees.
Treasury Shares: Landmark Federal Supreme Court Ruling
In decision BGE 150 II 369, the Federal Supreme Court examined the reissuance of treasury shares previously repurchased under an employee share ownership plan. Contrary to the position of the FTA, which brought the case before the Federal Supreme Court, the Court held that, provided the transaction is recognized in the accounts without affecting profit or loss, the difference between the reissuance price and the acquisition cost does not constitute taxable profit but a tax-neutral capital contribution. Circular No. 37A further clarifies that the difference between the market value at the time of transfer and the lower price paid by employees may be deductible as staff expenses, provided it is recognized accordingly in the accounts. However, for securities transfer stamp duty purposes, where shares are transferred to employees at a preferential price, the relevant amount is the purchase price, not the employment benefit granted. By contrast, no securities transfer stamp duty is payable on free shares or gratuitous allocations of shares, as these do not involve a transfer for consideration.
Options at Closing: Employment Income Rather Than Capital Gains
Where unlisted employee options are exercised or settled in cash at closing, this generally gives rise to taxable employment income. Accelerated vesting may affect the timing and amount of taxation. In the case of internationally mobile employees, the working days during the vesting period, withholding tax and correct reporting in the salary certificate must also be taken into account.
Management Rollover: Investment or Employment Income?
Where management reinvests part of the sale proceeds in the acquisition holding company, a distinction must be made between a private investment and remuneration for services rendered. Market-standard terms, genuine shareholder rights and a transparent valuation support the classification as an investment. However, preferential terms (sweet equity) and good/bad leaver provisions do not automatically constitute employment income and must be assessed on a case-by-case basis. In the case of employee shares valued using a formula, a subsequent exit may give rise to a taxable gain. The decisive factors are the specific arrangements and the canton responsible for the tax assessment. It is therefore advisable to obtain advance tax rulings.
Shares and Earn-outs
Phantom shares do not confer an equity interest in the company. Payments are generally treated as taxable employment income. In the case of earn-outs, the decisive question is whether the payment genuinely constitutes additional purchase consideration or remuneration for continued employment. At company level, the economic allocation of costs, their accounting treatment and any intra-group recharges must be examined.
Matters to Clarify Before Signing
The parties should clarify at an early stage which participation rights will be transferred, exercised or settled at closing, and who will bear the resulting taxes and social security contributions. Particular attention should be paid to leaver provisions, withholding tax obligations and the treatment of these matters in the purchase price calculation. Clear provisions in the purchase agreement help reduce disputes and subsequent tax or other assessments after closing.
Conclusion
The tax implications are largely determined at the stage when the employee share plan and the M&A transaction are structured. Early coordination of the participation terms, purchase agreement and tax treatment helps avoid costly surprises. The valfor Tax Team supports companies, investors and management with structuring, due diligence and obtaining advance tax rulings.
An article by Regina Schlup Guignard